Troubleshooting "Docker Not Adding User To MariaDB With Dockerfile"

• Dockerfile: A text file with instructions to build a Docker image (blueprint for a container).
• MariaDB: An open-source relational database management system.
• Docker: A platform for running applications in isolated containers.

The Problem:

By default, the official MariaDB Docker image creates a user named "mysql" with a specific user ID (UID) and group ID (GID). However, sometimes you might want to use a different user in your Dockerfile for security reasons.

Here's where the issue arises: If you try to specify a new user in your Dockerfile, it might not override the default "mysql" user created by the MariaDB image.

Possible Reasons:

• Missing Information: You might not be providing all the necessary details (UID and GID) when creating the user in your Dockerfile.
• Conflicting Instructions: Your Dockerfile instructions to create a user might be placed after the MariaDB image's built-in user creation.

Solutions:

• Use Existing User: If you don't necessarily need a new user, you can leverage the default "mysql" user created by the MariaDB image and set its password using environment variables in your Dockerfile.
• Override the Default User: There are ways to instruct the MariaDB image to use your specified user during the build process. This might involve environment variables or specific commands in your Dockerfile.

This approach leverages the official MariaDB Docker image's built-in functionality to create a user.

# Use the official MariaDB image
FROM mariadb:latest

# Set environment variables for user creation (optional)
ENV MYSQL_USER my_custom_user
ENV MYSQL_PASSWORD my_secure_password
ENV MYSQL_DATABASE my_database

# Let the MariaDB image handle user creation
CMD ["mysqld"]

Explanation:

• The CMD instruction simply runs the mysqld command, which starts the MariaDB server. The MariaDB image will automatically create the user and database based on the provided environment variables (if defined).
• We define optional environment variables:
  • MYSQL_USER: This sets the username for the database user.
  • MYSQL_DATABASE: This sets the name of the database to create.
• We use the mariadb:latest image as the base.

Explicit User Creation (Less Common):

This approach explicitly creates a user within your Dockerfile. Note that this might conflict with the MariaDB image's default user creation if not done carefully.

# Use the official MariaDB image
FROM mariadb:latest

# Define a specific user ID (UID) and group ID (GID) (optional)
ARG USER_ID=1000
ARG GROUP_ID=1000

# Create the user with the specified UID and GID
RUN groupadd -r mysql -g $GROUP_ID && useradd -r -u $USER_ID -g mysql mysql

# ... rest of your Dockerfile instructions ...

# Start the MariaDB server
CMD ["mysqld"]

• Finally, the CMD instruction starts the MariaDB server.
• The remaining part of your Dockerfile would likely involve setting up the database and other configurations.
• The RUN instruction creates a group named mysql with the specified GID and then creates a user named mysql with the specified UID and assigns it to the mysql group.
• We define optional arguments for user ID (USER_ID) and group ID (GROUP_ID).

This method involves creating an entrypoint script that executes after the image is built. The script can then handle user creation based on your specifications.

Here's a basic example:

Dockerfile:

FROM mariadb:latest

# Define optional environment variables
ENV MYSQL_USER my_custom_user
ENV MYSQL_PASSWORD my_secure_password
ENV MYSQL_DATABASE my_database

COPY entrypoint.sh /docker-entrypoint.sh

# Set the entrypoint to the script
ENTRYPOINT ["/docker-entrypoint.sh"]

CMD ["mysqld"]

entrypoint.sh:

#!/bin/bash

# Check if environment variables are set
if [ -z "$MYSQL_USER" ] || [ -z "$MYSQL_PASSWORD" ] || [ -z "$MYSQL_DATABASE" ]; then
  echo "ERROR: Missing environment variables for user creation"
  exit 1
fi

# Create the user using mysqladmin with provided details
mysqladmin -u root create "$MYSQL_USER"@"%" identified by "$MYSQL_PASSWORD"

# Create the database (optional)
mysqladmin -u root create "$MYSQL_DATABASE"

# Start the MariaDB server
CMD ["mysqld"]

• Finally, the script calls the mysqld command to start the MariaDB server.
• If the variables are set, it uses mysqladmin with the root user to create the desired user and database.
• The entrypoint.sh script checks if the environment variables are set.
• The ENTRYPOINT instruction sets the script to be executed when the container starts.
• We copy a script named entrypoint.sh into the container at /docker-entrypoint.sh.
• We define environment variables similar to the previous example.

Multi-Stage Builds:

This approach uses a multi-stage Docker build process. In the first stage, we create a temporary image to handle user creation. In the second stage, we copy only the necessary files from the first stage and start the MariaDB server.

Here's a simplified example:

# Stage 1: User Creation
FROM mariadb:latest

RUN groupadd -r mysql && useradd -r -u 1000 -g mysql mysql

# Stage 2: Final Image
FROM debian:slim

# Copy only necessary files from stage 1
COPY --from=0 /var/lib/mysql /var/lib/mysql

# Start the MariaDB server with user set to 'mysql' (created in stage 1)
CMD ["mysqld"]

• Finally, we start the MariaDB server.
• We copy only the required data directory (/var/lib/mysql) from the first stage, which contains the user information.
• The second stage uses a minimal image like debian:slim.
• The first stage (mariadb:latest) creates the user mysql with specific UID and GID.

Note:

• Always ensure proper access control within the container for security reasons.
• The multi-stage build approach can be more complex to manage but offers a cleaner final image without unnecessary files from the MariaDB image.